Our Menu

Each day we make 6-12 different flavours of cupcakes for walk-ins. Selection dwindles as the day goes on and sometimes these sell out. You can pre-order a daily assortment any time up to the day before and you will receive a mix of about 6 flavours of the day! Flavours are not determined ahead of time.

If you prefer to choose your assortment we post the flavours each morning to our Instagram @milkandwatercakeshop and Facebook Page. You can call in to reserve once we post, or you can come in during shop hours to choose from our display case! We have hundreds available for walk-ins each day.

For custom orders, a minimum of 12 cupcakes per flavour is required.

For custom vegan orders, a minimum of 6 cupcakes is required

For all other custom items (cookies, mini cheesecakes, etc.), we ask for a minimum of 12, per flavour, to be ordered.

Cupcakes

Quantities & Pricing

1 Cupcake

$4

6 Cupcakes

$20

12 Cupcakes

$35

Cakes

Choose your size, flavour, and colour you’d like for the icing. Cakes are two layers and filled and decorated with buttercream frosting. We can also write a message on top if you’d like! Please include all info in your order request.

Cake Sizes & Prices

Cutie Cake (one layer) // Serves 4-6

$20

6" Heart Cake // Serves 6-8

$30

6" Cake // Serves 6-10

$40

8" Cake // Serves 10-15

$45

9" Heart Cake // Serves 15-20

$40

9" Cake // Serves 15-20

$50

10" Cake // Serves 20-35

$60

12" Cake // Serves 35-50

$80

Cookies

Chocolate chip is available in store daily with a weekly rotating flavour as well!

1 Cookie

$2

12 Cookies

$15

1 Iced Cookie

$2.50

12 Iced Cookies

$20

Bars and Brownies

1 Bar

$4

6 Bars

$20

12 Bars

$35

Mini Cheesecakes

1 Cheesecake

$3.50

6 Cheesecakes

$18

12 Cheesecakes

$32

Popular Flavours

Ready to place your order? See how here.